Tobias "Toby" Matthews (
hisheartsdesire) wrote2015-11-08 06:56 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Entry tags:
[ic] Contact

Tobias may one day learn to change the greeting on his voicemail. Until then, there's only the default.
audio | text | video | action
**Some thread content may be NSFW**
no subject
After a moment's silence,] Thank you. I've been trying, after all.
[Still, though. This doesn't tell Toby what Edgeworth wants, or why he'd wanted to know.]
So you've decided what sort of person I am. If I might ask, what for? I mean, why did you want to know?
no subject
[He shrugs, and goes back to his drink.]
I wanted to see if I was wrong about you, as well.
[His tone is stilted when he talks about flawed assumptions, but it quickly becomes as cool and clinical as it was before. As if he was talking about an interesting, but troubling case, and not someone he once considered a friend. However, despite his attempts at cold neutrality, there's still a slight, breathy edge to his tone. He continues to drink, but he's gripping the glass tightly, and his posture is a hair too stiff for him to relax. These are the only hints of emotion that get past his icy exterior.]
no subject
[Toby goes quiet again as he studies Edgeworth for some moments. He can see the other man's slight stiffness and the way he clutches his glass. Then he sighs like he's been holding his breath for too long.]
You know, drinks with you used to be more relaxing and enjoyable rather than... whatever things are right now. Good thing I wasn't expecting things to just go back to the way they used to be. [A small sip of his drink.] What got you thinking about your assumptions or how wrong you were about me in the first place? You seemed perfectly content completely abandoning me for months.
[Edgeworth was the one who had cut Toby off without warning after discovering he couldn't take Drew down without implicating Toby as well. He pushed Toby toward the extreme, and altogether avoided his existence until now. That counts as abandonment, doesn't it?]
no subject
...there was a boy.
[He had explained, however vaguely, what had changed his mind. But now is the time for more specific details.]
Some teenage brat on a power trip. [He snorts and shakes his head] He had hurt someone who I felt... responsible for, and I wanted him behind bars before his tantrum harmed anyone else. However...
[He breathes in and scowls at the table, shifting uncomfortably in his seat]
...a friend of his intervened. He told me about his powers, and warned me that imprisonment could lead to disastrous results. The boy - he's a psychic, and a powerful one at that. So nullification...
[He sighs, and taps his finger against the glass]
Have you ever seen what happens when someone shakes up a can of soda, or beer, or anything of the sort? Anything carbonated. It's a similar principal. Nullifying him could have put his talents under pressure, and as soon as those restraints are removed...
[He sweeps his arm over the table, in a weak pantomime of an explosion]
...the results could have been lethal, not just for him, but for everyone around him. And, as much as I wanted to see that punk get his just desserts, I decided to take a risk and allow his friend to act as his parole officer. I put through the paperwork to put him in his custody instead, all the while expecting him to go back to his old ways. But...
[He purses his lips together, remaining silent for a moment]
He hasn't. Or at least, he hasn't yet. In fact, I dare say there were moments where the boy acted heroically. And I...
[Edgeworth doesn't admit that he's wrong. He never will. However...]
...it's given me food for thought. About a lot of things, to be honest.
no subject
Although he feels somewhat sick with irritation, he listens until Edgeworth finishes.]
And that's why you invited me out this evening, to see if or how I've changed from the... flippantly ignorant monster I was when I first arrived. [Toby scowls.]
How fortunate the boy had someone both considerate and reputable standing up for him. [Someone who probably is nothing like Edgeworth.] Well, I don't measure up to this boy you've mentioned, do I? But I've done what I can to make up for the damage I caused and the lives that I changed, ruined.
[Yet, that isn't enough, is it?]
no subject
[His tone is sharp and he's scowling back at Toby now, looking him in the eye again.]
I was starting to respect you, Toby. You were finally taking responsibility for your actions. You were finally putting self-pity behind you - or so I thought. Are you going to continue acting like an adult, or are you going to start acting like a child again?
no subject
The fire in his eyes doesn't quite go out so much as it fades into a more neutral expression.]
I'm not going to go back to that. [He huffs, perhaps childishly.] Just now, you reminded me of someone. I thought we were close, I trusted him, and then he turned his back on me. Abandoned me without warning. There's more to it, but really, all of that is beside the point because you aren't him.
To be frank, this... situation, the current state between us mirrors something that has happened before. The main difference is that he betrayed me in almost every possible way, whereas you— [Toby cuts himself off, takes a deep breath, and lets out a heavy sigh.] There's really no point in grudging against you, you aren't him, and I truly enjoyed our friendship. I want to believe there's still hope.
no subject
Most importantly, though, he remembers the people who gave him a chance, despite his own secrets and his own misdeeds. When he thinks on their kindness, though, he remembers Toby's calm acceptance of him, and the trust he had shown. His expression grows distant and he breathes heavily, shaking his head.]
...I'm not sure if there is. Toby...
[His voice is quiet and stiff, but when he looks up at him, his voice turns firm.]
How well did we know each other back then? How well did we honestly know one another?
no subject
I don't know. I guess... that when we first met, I saw someone who could use a little help. And that's all right, because everyone could use some once in a while. Sure, you were terribly cynical, but I thought I saw someone lonely in there. Someone who wanted to have friends, to have company, to relax even a little bit once in a while.
[He lets out a tired sigh.]
Beyond that, you have a reputation. And your pride. First and foremost, you uphold justice. You can't just sit back and watch people suffer or destroy each other. You're proactive. [A pause.] Shall I go on, or do you want to talk about me?
no subject
That... that won't be necessary. But as for you...
[He takes another heavy breath. Another sip from his drink.]
I thought that you were kind. Patient. Gentle, even. But unfortunately, I've known my fair share of kind, gentle people, none of whom were genuine about it. For them, softness was nothing but a mask, a distraction to hide a darker, more vicious nature. When I heard the news of what you had done, I assumed that you were cut from the same cloth as them. However...
[He swallows the lump in his throat and shifts in his chair, adjusting his position]
However, none of them would have taken responsibility for their actions the way you did. They would have continued their act for as long as they could get away with it, and as long as it suited them.
no subject
More importantly, Toby is still misleading people about the fact his power here doesn't work the same way it did back at home. It took some measure of adjusting to, and the fact is that he had performed many deceptions back home. Things might not be so different, Toby himself might not be so changed if it weren't for that. Should anyone here discover this, then what? The thought terrifies him.
Toby thinks that he should come out with it sometime. He maintains a neutral expression.]
I see. I understand now, Edgeworth. And I thank you for seeing some good in me—as well as change. [A pause. It's important to tread carefully.] For the longest time, I have been a believer that there is a certain level of deception involved in any relationship. That people will always have some secret or other.
What are your thoughts on that?
no subject
There was a time where I had taken that fact for granted, assuming it was the natural state of things. And that's what made relationships so dangerous. You could never tell what secrets a person held in their heart, nor what they would do with yours should they uncover them.
[He breathes out and grips his glass, not lifting it up]
So I avoided them altogether. It seemed safer that way. However...
[He shakes his head]
I've started to question the wisdom in that.
no subject
[He exhales a long, airy breath.]
Since coming here, hiding what I am and what I did has only caused problems. Not just for me, but others. Keeping these secrets... really hasn't been worth all of that. That said, I'm trying to be more open about it and am discovering people are far more accepting about it in this place, during these times.
[That's his way of dealing with the other secret he still keeps. Maybe in time, he'll mention it, but he doesn't want to ruin what's happening now.]
So, I guess all of this begs the question... What now?
[Where do they stand? Is this how it ends, a peaceful, accepting, and fairly understanding parting of ways? Are they starting sort of from scratch but not quite square one? Or are they at something of a neutral in-between?]
no subject
[He shrugs and shakes his head]
I don't know, and to be frank, I'm surprised that you still want anything to do with me. Our friendship, as it were, was based on misconceptions. Neither of us were as... kind as the other had hoped for. However...
[He meets Toby's gaze, his expression serious]
Whatever happens, I will hold no grudge against you. I will not hound you, I will not seek punishment, I will not rub salt in your wounds. It's true that you can't change what you've done. However, piling on additional penance won't do any good, either. Simply put, you're not the man I assumed you were when we last met. Like I've said, you've taken responsibility, as best as anyone in your situation can. So long as you continue to do so, I have no reason to mistreat you.
wrapping this thread up, i think
At any rate, they're not exactly starting from scratch or a blank slate, nor are they writing each other off. It's like finding neutral ground, and if their paths cross, then so be it. So again, he solemnly nods.]
Thanks. I think I get it.